Opinionated brands: Leave algorithmic palatability behind

Marketing is a combat sport.

IMA's Adam Knott identified the central dilemma facing brands today in The Ingenuity Group's Growth Leaders series: marketing is a combat sport, so pick your battles and win them deliberately. Too many brands attempt to do everything at once. But when you try to win everywhere, do you end up winning nowhere?

In a crowded market, standing out has never been harder. A fragmented media landscape, the rise of AI and agencies increasingly talking about the same things have made hedging the default: follow the trend report, borrow a familiar face, say nothing that could offend. For an SME, finding a space you can own is essential when you consider the cost of competing on digital channels. As Jessie McLaren Webb, Managing Director at Engage PR, argues, differentiation isn't about being louder; it's about having something credible and meaningful to say. A brand without a point of view is not safe. It is simply interchangeable.

As Melanie Lazarus , Ecosystem Engagement Director at Open Banking, points out, the stakes are rising: large language models draw directly on the conversations surrounding your brand, meaning authentic organic discourse now directly shapes discovery. In an increasingly automated world, conviction and genuine human connection matter more than ever.

Standing out has never looked so similar

At the 2026 FIFA World Cup, Nike , adidas , PUMA Group and New Balance all outfitted their players in near-identical fluorescent pink boots. Each decision was rational in isolation: pink reads brilliantly against green turf and smartphone screens. Collectively, however, it erased the visibility each brand paid for. Even Adidas CEO Bjørn Gulden admitted that landing on the exact same shade was "weird." Trade press speculated that the brands consulted the same trend data from WGSN. Whether true or not, the lesson stands: trends move faster than insight, and a brand that outsources its taste to a forecast inevitably ends up wearing everyone else's.

A hollowed-out brand underneath all that inertia

Nike built its dominance as a pioneer in innovation and culture, then deliberately steered away from that identity. In the 2010s, it consolidated regional product creation offices, including Hong Kong. Later, under former CEO John Donahoe, it pulled back from wholesale partners in favor of direct-to-consumer distribution. While stock markets initially rewarded these changes, by August 2026 shares had fallen roughly 78% from their 2021 peak, erasing more than $200 billion in value and exposing a hollowed-out brand beneath the corporate inertia.

Innovation is coming back. Elliott Hill's "Win Now" plan is rebuilding wholesale and refocusing on sport, and Nike's new 3D-printed product looks promising. However, with a Greater China reorganization rumoured following consecutive quarters of sluggish growth, Nike's ability to re-ignite its presence in key international markets

Purpose can be inherited, not acquired

Ben & Jerry's became a household name because its values were baked into its products and corporate governance alike. When Unilever acquired the brand in 2000 for $326 million, it agreed to preserve an independent board to protect that social mission. A quarter of a century later, that arrangement has unraveled: following the spin-off of The Magnum Ice Cream Company, six of eight independent board members stepped down in January 2026, pushing the governance dispute into the courts.

Sales have held up, with Ben & Jerry's growing 9.2% in Q2 2026, but the social contract that made the brand distinctive is now contested in public. Trust can be transferred on a balance sheet; conviction cannot. Every acquirer of a purpose-led brand inherits a promise it must either keep or renegotiate.

Transparency is not a point of view

Quince is world-leading on transparency, openly sharing margins and supply-chain information, and has grown past $2 billion in sales. Yet for its biggest campaign to date, and its first in the UK, it chose to rent a story rather than tell its own: David Schwimmer chasing a red sweater, a nod to a 2001 episode of Friends.

While the ad generated strong viewership, borrowed nostalgia carries borrowed context. Media coverage quickly shifted from cashmere to the actor's public political statements, a conversation the brand neither initiated nor controlled. Transparency informs customers how a product is made, but true brand building requires marketing and communication to champion your own supply chain decisions, product story, and core values rather than relying on borrowed narratives or celebrity noise. As Quince expands across the UK and Europe, the true opportunity lies in building authentic, proprietary narratives around its core values and target customer.

What ownership looks like

On running provides a compelling counterpoint. Since Roger Federer joined as a partner in 2019, On has paired rigorous product innovation with co-created cultural moments. Ambassador Zendaya now co-designs collections alongside her longtime collaborator Law Roach, launching dedicated lines, one accompanied by a film from Spike Jonze. The stories remain unmistakably On's, speaking clearly to a specific customer with finely calibrated product.

Conviction can also be quiet. Porter Yoshida & Co. has made bags in Japan since 1935 under its founder's motto, "one stitch, all soul", with every step from fabric development to sewing carried out domestically. In an era when transparency is becoming the baseline, unmistakable mastery of quality is a position no competitor can copy overnight.

And it applies at every scale. For Penna Healthwear's second-generation medical scrubs, a collection we designed, materials were developed deliberately from the yarn up around the needs of the care-workers who wear them, rather than taken from a white-label catalogue. Owned material development is slower than off-the-shelf. It is also the only kind a competitor cannot buy.

The evidence for conviction in hard times

Research by Ranjay Gulati, Nitin Nohria, and Franz Wohlgezogen examining 4,700 companies across three recessions revealed that only 9% emerged stronger than before. These outperforming companies did not rely solely on cost-cutting; they paired disciplined expense management with continued investment in growth. Defensive firms lagged behind, averaging 6% sales growth post-downturn compared to 13% for progressive peers.

McKinsey's Strategy and Value reinforces this principle: long-term vision and competitive advantage form the bedrock of durable enterprise value, and strategy fails when disconnected from resource allocation. Speed and AI adoption are tactical capabilities, not strategies. A defensible, distinctive position remains paramount.

The Ownership Loop: a working theory

Synthesising these cases, we propose that perceived brand value is rebuilt through four acts of ownership, each reinforcing the next:

  1. Own your product. Deliberate design, identifiable innovation and material development that competitors cannot buy off the shelf.

  2. Own your story. Narratives built from your product and values.

  3. Own your culture. Participate in culture as a co-creator, not as the sponsor of borrowed moments.

  4. Own your choices. Pick your battles, say no, and invest in customised insights rather than retreating to the trend report.

When all four align, conviction becomes recognisable, recognition becomes trust, and trust becomes the pricing power that funds the next round of ownership. When any one is outsourced, whether to a forecaster, a celebrity, a white-label supplier or a quarterly target, the loop breaks and the brand drifts toward a sea of fluorescent sameness.

At Full Circle Creative, we help brands along that journey, from product-creation processes and material strategy to brand positioning, across our studios in London, Paris and Hong Kong. Interested in building a brand with a point of view, or in more articles like this? Book a call with us.

Written by Euan Neale

Sources:

  1. SGI Europe – Football in pink (2026 World Cup boots): https://www.sgieurope.com/product/football-in-pink/121795.article

  2. Footy Headlines – adidas CEO on the pink boots overlap: https://www.footyheadlines.com/4759083762/adidas-ceo-apologizes-for-bizarre-pink-boots-overlap-at-2026-world-cup.html

  3. Invezz – Nike stock lost $200B since its 2021 highs: https://invezz.com/news/2026/08/18/nike-stock-lost-200b-in-value-since-its-2021-highs-what-is-ailing-the-sports-giant/

  4. Qatar Tribune – Nike's new Asia structure: https://www.qatar-tribune.com/article/257329/business/nike-eyes-bigger-role-for-china-under-new-asia-structure

  5. People Matters – Nike closes tech offices in Atlanta, China and Poland: https://anz.peoplemattersglobal.com/news/strategic-hr/nike-to-relocate-tech-operations-as-job-cuts-reach-1400-49594

  6. Grocery Gazette – Ben & Jerry's: the long fight to keep an activist brand independent: https://www.grocerygazette.co.uk/2026/03/25/ben-jerrys-the-long-fight-to-keep-an-activist-brand-independent/

  7. Bloomberg Government – Ben & Jerry's independent directors edged out: https://news.bgov.com/esg/ben-jerrys-independent-directors-edged-out-in-magnum-feud

  8. Magnum Ice Cream Company – 2026 half-year results: https://news.magnumicecream.com/2026-half-year-results/

  9. Adweek – David Schwimmer chases the perfect red sweater: https://www.adweek.com/creativity/david-schwimmer-chases-the-perfect-red-sweater-in-quinces-biggest-ever-campaign/

  10. Retail Times – Quince's first UK campaign: https://retailtimes.co.uk/david-schwimmer-stars-in-quinces-first-uk-campaign-bringing-back-the-iconic-red-sweater

  11. SportsPro – On, Federer and Zendaya: https://www.sportspro.com/analysis/sponsorship-marketing/on-running-federer-zendaya-ad-nike-olympics-cybersecurity-top-sponsors/

  12. FashionNetwork – On unveils its second collection with Zendaya: https://uk.fashionnetwork.com/news/On-unveils-its-second-collection-with-zendaya,1872669.html

  13. Oliver Spencer – Porter-Yoshida & Co: https://oliverspencer.co.uk/collections/porter-yoshida-co

  14. Harvard Business Review – Roaring Out of Recession (Gulati, Nohria, Wohlgezogen, 2010): https://hbr.org/2010/03/roaring-out-of-recession

  15. McKinsey – Author Talks: Strategy and Value: https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/mckinsey-on-books/author-talks-why-you-cant-separate-strategy-from-value-and-vice-versa

Next
Next

Which department owns digital product passports?